The arguments presented in the analysis of Mary Midgley’s ‘Trying Out One’s New Sword’ are not comprehensive in identifying some of the errors in the work. The critique points out that Midgley is successful in arguing against moral isolationism because she presents solid facts about the differences that exist in understanding different cultures (Midgley, 1981). The critique, however, does not explore the fundamental basis of all cultures, inherently agreeing with the argument presented by Midgley instead of exploring the basis of understanding the traditions of other cultures.
The support for Midgley’s position is constructed on the basis of her own argument, and there are no outside references used in the critique to justify any objections. The critique does not present an objection to the argument against moral isolationism, instead backing up the theories already presented by Midgley. Therefore, there is no insightful analysis of the evidence that has been presented by the author, instead using her own argument to justify the critique. Additional outside references such as other arguments for and against moral isolationism would have helped to make the argument much stronger.[“Write my essay for me?” Get help here.]
The critique correctly points out that Midgley is not successful in refuting the theory of normative ethical relativism. There is evidence presented to show this fact, and it is linked to the common theories explaining behavior and cultural differences (Midgley, 1981).[Need an essay writing service? Find help here.] However, again, there are no outside sources to make this argument stronger, and this proves a significant challenge in making a convincing case of the errors in Midgley’s argument. Making use of other arguments for and against normative ethical relativism would help to clarify some of the errors and oversights presented in Midgley’s argument. It would make it much easier to present a coherent critique that is based on facts and observable evidence.[Click Essay Writer to order your essay]
Midgley, M. (1981). Trying Out One’s New Sword, from Heart and Mind. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.